Closing Shop examines what it takes to fix a modern car and calls on lawmakers to give drivers a choice of where to get it repaired.
The Repair Association (Repair.org) is releasing Closing Shop, a report on how automakers restrict access to the software, tools, and data needed to fix today's cars. The report estimates that independent repair shops spend 83 million hours a year obtaining and getting manufacturer software to work. That's the annual working time of about 42,000 full-time technicians, valued at roughly $12 billion using a shop rate of $140 an hour.
A mechanic used to be able to look up a wiring diagram and get to work. Today, a shop may have to buy a subscription, connect a brand-specific adapter, and log in to a manufacturer's system before it can diagnose a bad taillight or install a replacement part. An independent shop that services many makes has to repeat that process across brands. A dealership can spread the cost of a single brand's tools across thousands of jobs. When the local shop turns down a repair, the driver may have to travel farther, wait longer, or pay a higher hourly rate.
Among the mechanics surveyed, 88 percent said they had turned away work in the past year because they lacked the software or tools to do it. For repairs that required manufacturer software, the median time reported by respondents who estimated that work was 75 minutes. In August 2026, the team priced a single seat of software access across five major automakers at $15,878 a year. That's before a shop buys the adapters and other equipment it needs to connect to the vehicles.
Annual software and service information for one technician: GM $4,328, Ford $4,035, Stellantis $3,735, Hyundai $2,280, and Toyota $1,500. Source: Closing Shop.
How the team did the work
The report was written by Kyle Wiens of iFixit, Nathan Proctor of U.S. PIRG Education Fund, and Kevin O'Reilly of FULU. The team asked independent repair professionals how often they needed factory software, where they got stuck, and how much time they spent getting access. The researchers checked prices on manufacturer and authorized reseller sites and read the onerous license agreements shops have to accept. Those records show what a shop must buy and what it is allowed to do once it pays.
What lawmakers should do
Give owners control over their wireless vehicle data. Mandate that manufacturers equip their vehicles with a standardized platform for accessing telematics repair data. This will allow independent mechanics to compete with car dealerships. Wireless repair data should go directly to owners, who should be the ones deciding who has access to their repair information. They bought the car; they should have direct access to the information needed to fix it.
Stop requiring secure gateways for routine repairs. No manufacturer should require a business license to fix a seat, a screen, or a trunk latch. Access to functions that are genuinely security-related should run through standardized, manufacturer-neutral vetting similar to NASTF and SERMI, not through per-brand fees. Eliminate business obstacles to accessing and programming parts.
Allow vehicle owners to repair anything on their car. Today, authentication and access are at the manufacturer's discretion and can be repriced or revoked at will. Some even require a business license. Require every manufacturer to support a standard protocol for authenticating independent tools. Proprietary authentication only allows the manufacturers to charge whatever they want, to whomever they want, whenever they want. Limiting access is unfair to car owners and independent repair shops who need up-to-date and fast information.
Make service information and basic diagnostic software free. Publicly accessible documentation will enable innovation and encourage more local repair activity. Tesla already does it. The engineering is paid for with the car. Thirteen years of experience living under the automotive MOU have shown that "fair and reasonable" means nothing.
Cap software prices. High per-manufacturer prices inordinately penalize independent shops and DIY mechanics. Limit the total price of everything required to repair a car to $100/month or $1,000/year.
It’s time we restore the Right to Repair our vehicles.