repair.org
A report on automotive right to repair

Closing Shop

How carmakers turned repair software into a toll booth, and what it's costing every driver in America.

1.25 hrsMedian estimated time per repair that needs manufacturer software
42,000skilled technicians' worth of time lost to software friction each year
$12B/yrthe value of that time at documented shop rates
88%of mechanics we surveyed have turned away repairs for lack of software tools
+122%rise in auto insurance prices since 2012, against 40% for all consumer prices
Executive summary

Software locks and excessive fees waste some $12 billion a year of mechanics' time

When a car needs service, a small yellow wrench lights up on the dash. The symbol is a hand tool, but it should be a laptop.

Fixing a modern car means talking to its computers. To find a failed sensor, release an electronic parking brake, or tell a new part which car it belongs to, a mechanic plugs a laptop or tablet into the vehicle. The wrench work can't start unless the mechanic has paid the manufacturer for permission to diagnose it.

This report measures the admission fee. We surveyed independent repair shops across the country, checked manufacturer software prices line by line, and read the contracts mechanics have to agree to. We mapped one brand's entire dealer network, then built a model of the time and money involved for you to get your car fixed.

Snap-on APOLLO+ diagnostic tablet in the driver's seat of a car
The modern toolbox: a diagnostic tablet in the driver's seat. Whether it is allowed to talk to the car is now a business decision made at the manufacturer. Credit: Snap-on.

You pay for this software through your insurance rates even if you never get your car fixed. Higher repair costs drive more expensive insurance claims, and the price of auto insurance has risen three times as fast as the rest of the economy since 2012. When independent mechanics can’t complete repairs because they lack the necessary software or subscriptions, that steers repair shops to authorized dealerships, and allows them to charge more. Massachusetts dealership rates run 36% higher than independent shops for the same work (Massachusetts, 2020).

New technology doesn't need to drive costs up. Software has the potential to speed repairs and lower the cost of diagnosing problems. Instead, automakers have deployed it in ways that make repair more cumbersome and riddled with paywalls.

All of these software restrictions add up. On repairs that need manufacturer software, about one in five at independent shops, the mechanics we surveyed spend an estimated 1.25 hours buying, downloading, logging in, and waiting. Across the country that is 83 million hours a year, the working time of 42,000 technicians in a trade already short of them. At typical shop rates, that time is worth about $12 billion a year. Meanwhile, local mechanics are turning away work because they cannot access, or cannot afford, the software they need: 88% of the mechanics we surveyed turned away a repair in the past year for that reason.

Car ownership is increasingly stacked against consumers. Manufacturers transmit the data your car collects to their own dealerships, and GM sold driving data that ended up in insurers' hands. Service manuals now cost thousands of dollars a year from every brand but Tesla. Driver-assistance sensors need brand-specific calibration gear that most of the shops we surveyed do not have, and software ties replacement parts to a single car, which can prevent a working salvaged part from being reused.

Local independent mechanics keep communities running, especially in rural America. More than a million Americans live over 100 miles from the nearest Nissan dealer. When the neighborhood shop cannot afford a brand's software, those drivers lose their local repair option.

We believe it's time for lawmakers to act to protect this local repair infrastructure before it's too late. We have five recommendations for legislators:

  1. Give owners control over their wireless vehicle data.
  2. Stop requiring secure gateways for regular repairs.
  3. Allow vehicle owners to repair anything on their car.
  4. Make service information and basic diagnostic software free.
  5. Cap software prices at $100 a month or $1,000 a year per car.

Chapter 1

Telematics: the data your car transmits

A Lexus owner's phone buzzes with a red exclamation point beside the car's oil health and a button: "contact your Lexus dealer to schedule a maintenance appointment." A Honda owner gets a brake warning that says to "have your vehicle checked by a dealer immediately." Dodge puts it on the dashboard: "visit an authorized dealer."

Honda Accord infotainment screen showing Update Is Unavailable, have your vehicle checked by the dealer
An 11th-generation Honda Accord, September 2025: "Update Is Unavailable. Have your vehicle checked by the dealer." Credit: Redditor ColorfulImaginati0n.
u/ColorfulImaginati0nPhoto via r/11thGenAccord

Manufacturers have a built-in advantage for scheduling maintenance. They use the data your car generates, and their remote access to the car's display, to steer drivers to their dealerships. Meanwhile, vehicle owners don't have the information behind the warning or a way to provide it to their preferred mechanic.

Most new cars send data over the cellular network, a capability the industry calls telematics: fault codes, oil life, location, and in some cars how hard you brake and accelerate. GM sends owners monthly diagnostic emails, and its dealer maintenance notifications send some alerts to an owner's preferred participating dealer if the owner opts in. The dealer can then contact the owner to help schedule service.

Toyota app vehicle health report screen
Toyota's app scores the car's health and puts a dealer appointment one tap away. Screenshot from Toyota marketing materials, via U.S. PIRG Education Fund, My Car, My Data.

The 2026 My Car, My Data report from U.S. PIRG Education Fund, our co-author on this report, describes what mechanics fear: "A two-tiered repair model, where independent shops conduct repairs with less information, less powerful diagnostic tools, and higher associated costs than authorized dealerships." Manufacturers, the report notes, have "a track record of using telematics to enable paywalls for vehicle features, allowing them to charge owners for use of heated seats, in-car navigation or other features," and have "aggressively opposed reforms that grant car owners control over the data."

The same data could make independent repair better at servicing their customers. Chad Bechtel of Precision Tune Auto Care described what he would do with it: the check-engine light comes on, and his shop calls the customer. "We already [have] the parts ordered, how far away are you?" This isn't science fiction: fleet operators already run their trucks exactly this way. Manufacturers do not let independent shops have the data to offer the same service.

Glenn Wilder, who owns Wilder Brothers Tire Pros in North Scituate, Massachusetts, says the dealer's edge is getting the customer in the door for the diagnosis. After that, most people will not push back:

"[Most people will not look the dealer] in the face and say, 'I'm going to take that to my guy and get that checked out for a second opinion.'" Glenn Wilder

Our co-author's earlier report warned that manufacturers "could use telematic connections to 'verify' replacement parts, similar to parts pairing practices in the electronics and agriculture industry," which would let a manufacturer decide over the air whether a part a shop just installed is allowed to work. Its conclusion stands: "Vehicle owners and mechanics deserve access to vital vehicle data, just as we can access odometer levels or error codes."

They are already selling your data but you can't have it

New York Times reporter Kashmir Hill checked the app for her family's Chevrolet Bolt in January 2024. It said the family wasn't enrolled in Smart Driver, GM's driving-monitoring program, and gave her no access to her driving records.

Her husband later requested his file from LexisNexis. It contained details of 203 trips they had taken, including hard braking and rapid acceleration. GM blamed the app's misleading display on a software bug.

The FTC says GM sold Smart Driver data to LexisNexis and Verisk, which compiled reports for insurers. The records included hard braking, acceleration, speed, and trips. Some drivers discovered the reports only after insurers raised their premiums or denied or canceled their coverage.

In January 2026, the FTC finalized a settlement barring GM from sending location and driving-behavior data to consumer reporting agencies for five years. The order also requires separate consent for unrelated uses of that data, with exceptions for uses such as safety and repair.

Owners should be able to decide who receives the data from their vehicles. The 2012 Massachusetts right-to-repair law and the national agreement that followed it exempted data sent wirelessly. Massachusetts voters closed that gap in 2020, and some manufacturers' answer was to turn the feature off: Subaru and Kia disabled telematics on 2022 cars sold in Massachusetts rather than share the data.

Vehicle owners should be able to control where their data goes. The driver generated the data, the driver's car collected it, and the driver should decide who sees it.

You own the car. You should control its data.


Chapter 2

Every driver pays: the insurance bill

Since 2012, the consumer price index for motor vehicle insurance has more than doubled. The overall consumer price index rose just 40% over the same period. Nearly every state requires drivers to carry insurance, so this is a bill that nearly all drivers have to pay.

Insurance premium increases are driven by "claim severity," what each claim costs to settle. Software costs are adding up, with the average fee for calibrating driver-assistance sensors on a collision almost doubling in five years, to about $500. Scans, software fees, and calibrations can become part of the repair estimate an insurer pays.

Car insurance is, for most, a mandatory bill that has risen three times faster than inflation since 2012. Those costs have several drivers: used-car values, parts prices, litigation, weather. Software repair hurdles are not the sole reason for the increase, but they touch every driver in America, including the ones who have never heard of a secure gateway.

Line chart, indexed to 2012. Motor vehicle insurance prices rose 122% between 2012 and 2025, while all consumer prices rose 40%.Car insurance is up 122% since 2012. Everything else is up 40%.1001401802202012201420162018202020222024Auto insurance +122%Overall economy +40%index, 2012 = 100 (BLS annual averages)
Figure 1. Motor vehicle insurance relative to overall consumer prices, indexed to 2012 (Bureau of Labor Statistics series CUUR0000SETE and CUUR0000SA0, annual averages).

There is a second way drivers pay: when a repair estimate climbs past what the car is worth, the insurer totals the car. In 2025 insurers classified 23.1% of all claims as total losses, the highest point in the 2013-2025 national claims series kept by CCC Intelligent Solutions, an insurance claims data company. CCC calls that "a new high watermark for the industry" and points to older vehicles, rising repair costs, and changes in which claims get filed.

Line chart. The share of all claims flagged as total losses rose from 14.0% in 2013 to a record 23.1% in 2025.More claims end as total losses0%5%10%15%20%25%2012201420162018202020222024202523.1%
Figure 2. The share of all claims ending as total losses. The axis begins in 2012 to match Figure 1; CCC's published series begins in 2013. Source: CCC Intelligent Solutions, Crash Course 2026, Figure 17.

Software hurdles show up in these repair costs. In 2025, calibration line items, the sensor resets a shop must run after replacing a windshield, a bumper, or a camera, appeared on 28.3% of repair claims (claims where the car is fixed rather than totaled), up 30% in a single year. A separate CCC analysis says the average calibration charge nearly doubled in five years, to about $500 per repaired vehicle. That charge lands on the repair estimate. But CCC does not say that calibration costs caused the record total-loss rate, so we do not make that claim here.

ABPA: upstream drivers of rising total loss determinations
Figure 3. Why more cars get totaled: rising repair costs (parts, calibration costs, labor) meet falling vehicle values. Graphic courtesy of the Automotive Body Parts Association, "TOTALED: The Real Costs of Vehicle Loss" (2026), used with permission.

Software fees are driving repair costs higher than ever.


Chapter 3

Software: paying for permission

A simple brake job

In the fall of 2025, a Hyundai Ioniq 5 N owner set out to change his own brake pads, a job he had done on other cars for decades. The pads themselves come off with hand tools. But the new electronic parking brake has to be put into a service mode to retract the rear calipers. Being a careful owner, he bought a week of Hyundai's repair software for $60 plus an approved adapter for about $2,000.

Even that didn't work: the NASTF industry registry (the National Automotive Service Task Force) only works for professionals with proof of business standing, not shade-tree mechanics like him.

Hyundai J2534 diagnostic tool in Brake Pad Change Mode showing a Test Failure error
Hyundai's diagnostic tool in "Brake Pad Change Mode," failing with "Test Failure !!!"
u/SoultronicPearScreenshot via r/Ioniq5N
Hyundai J2534 tool Login NASTF dialog asking for a VSP ID and two-factor code
After an update, the same tool demands a login to the NASTF security registry, which does not issue accounts to individual owners. Screenshots: u/SoultronicPear.
u/SoultronicPearScreenshot via r/Ioniq5N
"This is madness. We're not talking about locks; we're talking about brake pads. The car is great, but Hyundai's treatment of its customers and its attempts to force dealer visits are borderline criminal (if not criminal)." Hyundai owner SoultronicPear, October 2025

The situation isn't much better for independent repair shops, which can't afford to get every technician certified or buy a repair tool for every bay (Hyundai's own dealer tool costs about $6,000). To its credit, Hyundai widened access for aftermarket adapters after the story spread. But the point stands: a brake job now includes a licensing decision, and the manufacturer makes it.

Fixing cars now requires navigating through a series of arbitrary software systems and locks.

The Software Tollbooth

A modern car is a computer network with wheels. Nearly every function runs through a computer module, and a mechanic who wants to diagnose or fix the car has to talk to those computers.

Massachusetts' 2012 right-to-repair law and the national agreement that followed require manufacturers to sell independent mechanics the same diagnostic and repair software their dealers use. But they failed to cap prices, and they've spiraled out of control. The cost is manageable for dealerships that buy just one brand's software and spread the cost across every car they see. An independent shop that works on everything needs a subscription for every badge in the lot and spreads the cost across far fewer cars.

High Fees Hit Small Shops the Hardest

To work on Stellantis vehicles (Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, Ram, Fiat), an independent shop needs:

Diagnostic software: wiTECH 2.0. The subscription that lets the shop ask the car what is wrong.
$1,760/yr
Repair information: TechAuthority. Critical wiring diagrams, repair procedures, part numbers. This information is free in other industries.
$1,975/yr
Reprogramming a part ("flashing a module"). Electronic parts don't work without software, and instead of letting you transfer software from the existing module, they charge you to flash it with new firmware. Sold one repaired module at a time.
$39/VIN
The manufacturer's laptop adapter: MDP+. This is Stellantis' proprietary adapter; generic J2534 adapters don't work consistently.
$1,850
Laptops and other tooling. A Windows laptop, a reliable internet connection, an account for each mechanic. Then the shop can ask the car what is wrong.
 $1,000+

That is one manufacturer. A shop that wants software access to five major manufacturers pays $15,878 a year before it earns a dollar. Those are prices for one technician, checked on manufacturer and authorized-reseller sites in August 2026. A shop with several bays pays more.

Bar chart. Annual single-seat software cost for five manufacturers: GM $4,328, Ford $4,035, Stellantis $3,735, Hyundai $2,280, Toyota $1,500 a year. Diagnostics and service information are priced separately by every brand except GM and Toyota.GM$4,328$4,328/yrsingle bundle since 2023Ford$1,200$2,835$4,035/yrStellantis$1,760$1,975$3,735/yr+ $1,850 adapter, $39 per VIN/yearHyundai$1,680$600$2,280/yrToyota$1,500$1,500/yrincludes service infodiagnostic softwareservice information
Figure 4. What one seat of software access costs per brand, per year (prices checked August 2026; rounded to dollars). Diagnostics and service information are usually separate products. Adapters, per-vehicle flash tokens, and multi-seat licenses are extra. The five-brand total depends on tier and channel; our checked run landed at $15,878 a year.

Locking Owners Out

Aftermarket scan tools used to be able to solve the problem with one tool for most brands, but they are losing ground. On newer cars, manufacturers install "secure gateways," software locks that refuse an aftermarket tool unless the tool has been specially authorized or the mechanic buys the manufacturer's own software.

Gateways have a legitimate job. In 2015, two security researchers took remote control of a Jeep through its cellular connection, and keeping remote access away from the engine immobilizer and the brakes is sensible. The Massachusetts law and the national agreement both allow it.

Autel diagnostic tool topology view of a car's control modules and networks
A diagnostic tool's map of one car's control modules and the networks that link them, with faulted modules in red. Credit: Autel.

But manufacturers used this as an excuse to lock up everyday repairs, not just security functions. Starting with some 2021 models, Mercedes put ordinary service functions like clearing codes and installing new headlights behind a secure gateway. Stellantis locks every write command on every module. Its own documentation says the gateway "gates all data" coming into the car and blocks "intrusive diagnostics such as bi-directional controls."

These innocent-seeming controls are locking people out of repairing their own vehicles. The two Jeep researchers said as much ten years later: with a gateway in place, the systems that talk to the outside world "don't necessarily talk to things like the brakes or the steering."

Locking the electronic seat controller does not protect the car. It protects the repair revenue of the dealership.

Mechanics Are Stuck Doing Busywork

Ask technicians what the software costs them and they talk about lost time. Setting up accounts. Managing licenses across multiple laptops. Support calls. Progress bars. Instead of just replacing the broken part, technicians have to navigate registration forms, pay fees, and clear software obstacles.

For a repair that needs manufacturer software, the median estimated time among the mechanics we surveyed is 1.25 hours, or 75 minutes. That's time you're paying for that is not being used to diagnose or fix your vehicle. It is busywork: buying software, downloading, logging in, and waiting.

Donut chart. Is manufacturer software access a burden? Of 51 responses: Large burden 33, Moderate 11, Small or slight 4, Not a burden 3. Base: 51 survey responses.Is manufacturer software access a burden?51 survey responsesLarge burden64.7%Moderate21.6%Small or slight7.8%Not a burden5.9%
Figure 5. Of the mechanics we surveyed, 94% call the time and money spent on manufacturer software a burden on their business; 65% call it a large one.
Donut chart. How often do issues require tech support? Of 50 responses: Occasionally 24, Sometimes 10, Often 12, Always 4. Base: 50 valid responses; excludes one N/A answer.How often do issues require tech support?50 valid responses; excludes one N/A answerOccasionally48.0%Sometimes20.0%Often24.0%Always8.0%
Figure 6. None of the mechanics we surveyed said they could consistently use manufacturer software without tech support.

Technicians overwhelmingly report that manufacturer software is poor quality and hard to use. Half of the mechanics we surveyed said they need technical support occasionally when using manufacturer software, and a third said often or always.

The hours add up. About 20% of repairs at independent shops currently need manufacturer software. Multiply the median time across the country's independent repair volume and our model estimates it costs 83 million hours of mechanics' time a year. That is equivalent to one working year for 42,000 full-time technicians, about 5% of all auto technicians in the United States. (The model, its assumptions, and its range are in the methodology section.)

Eliminating time spent dealing with manufacturer software would free up the equivalent of 42,000 technicians.

The trade does not have technician capacity to spare. The Bureau of Labor Statistics counts 825,800 automotive service technicians in the US and expects about 66,200 openings a year. The National Automobile Dealers Association puts the annual shortfall at about 37,000 trained technicians. Ford's chief executive, Jim Farley, told Axios "I need 6,000 technicians in my dealerships on Monday morning" and has said the country will need 400,000 auto technicians over the next three years. Saving the time that Ford's convoluted software licensing wastes would cover a share of that.

Ford's own skilled trades alliance tells a different story. Its September report counts about 66,000 auto technician and mechanic openings a year, and finds that getting young people into the trade is not the problem: workers under 25 make up 15.5% of auto technicians, more than in the skilled trades overall. The pressure comes after they start. That's where manufacturers' obstacles limit potential and make the job less fulfilling.

What the time is worth

We assume a shop labor rate of $140 per hour, using PartsTech's 2025 survey (page 14) as a guide. At that rate, the software time on one repair is worth about $175 in mechanic labor. Nationally, that is roughly $12 billion a year.

This time isn't always a line item on your invoice. Our survey found a mix of three approaches: some shops charge a markup, some shops eat the cost, and some shops decline jobs that require gateway authentication.

Secure gateways began to appear in volume in the late 2010s, so many of the cars that independent shops see today were built before them. As gateway-era cars leave warranty and arrive at independent shops, the share of repairs that need manufacturer software will rise. If it reaches 30% by 2030, the value of the lost time reaches about $17 billion a year at $140 an hour.

“You better have time [for a BMW software update] ... That car has to be sitting somewhere for hours.” Independent mechanic, AAPEX 2025

Turned away at the door

88% of the mechanics we surveyed have turned away a repair in the past year because they lacked the software or tools to do it. Almost nine shops in ten turned away a paying customer whose repair they knew how to perform. The Auto Care Association's 2024 survey found the same pattern: 84% of shops rate access to vehicle data as extremely or very important to their business. Over half send up to five cars a month to the dealer over data they cannot get.

Donut chart. Spending on manufacturer tools and software, last 5 years. Of 49 responses: Increased significantly 30, Increased 14, Stayed the same 1, Decreased 1, N/A 3. Base: 49 nonblank survey responses; includes three N/A answers.Spending on manufacturer tools and software, last 5 years49 nonblank survey responses; includes three N/A answersIncreased significantly61.2%Increased28.6%Stayed the same2.0%Decreased2.0%N/A6.1%
Figure 7. 96% of the mechanics we surveyed who expressed a direction say spending on manufacturer tools and software rose over five years.
Donut chart. Repairs requiring immobilizer access, last 5 years. Of 51 responses: Increased significantly 22, Increased 21, Stayed the same 5, N/A 3. Base: 51 survey responses.Repairs requiring immobilizer access, last 5 years51 survey responsesIncreased significantly43.1%Increased41.2%Stayed the same9.8%N/A5.9%
Figure 8. 84% of the mechanics we surveyed report more repairs requiring gated immobilizer access than five years ago.

Where does the work go? To the dealer, when there is one. But that costs: Consumers' Checkbook's May 2024 investigation lists dealership hourly labor rates averaging 37% higher than independent-shop rates, and J.D. Power's 2024 study found drivers waiting an average of 5.2 days for a dealership service appointment, up from 4.8 days in 2023. And while manufacturers would prefer to have higher market share, they don’t have the capacity. Dealerships don't have enough technicians to take over the work independent shops do today. Our model estimates they would need to more than double their technician workforce, even as the industry struggles to fill existing jobs.

Software monopolies make everyone lose. The shop that wanted the job watches it drive away, and owners pay more for repairs.

Software shouldn't stop you from fixing your own car.


Chapter 4

Rural America pays most

In most of America the car is not optional. Nearly 90% of rural trips are by car, fewer than 3% of rural households use public transit, and about 40% of rural residents live where there is no transit at all.

Small shops, including rural ones, are also the shops the subscription fees punish the most, because a fixed annual fee is a tax. For a busy single-brand dealership, GM's $4,328-a-year software works out to just 27 cents per repair (the average dealership handles 16,252 repair orders a year). At a shop handling a mixture of brands that sees fifty GM vehicles a year, the same login costs $86.56 per repair, 325 times the dealer's rate for the same tool.

Line chart. One GM subscription of $4,328 a year divided by the number of GM vehicles a business services annually. A 50-vehicle rural shop pays $86.56 per vehicle; a dealership at NADA-average volume pays 27 cents.Software fees per repairOne GM subscription ($4,328/yr), divided by annual GM vehicles serviced$0$20$40$60$80$100501005002,00016,252vehicles of that brand serviced per year (log scale)rural shop, 50/yr: $86.56 per repairbusy all-makes shop: ~$14Average dealership: $0.27
Figure 9. One GM subscription divided by how many GM vehicles a business services in a year. The dealer barely notices it; the rural shop cannot justify it.

Mapping the desert

When brands get too expensive to service, independent shops can drop them altogether—leaving customers without a local repair option. We mapped what that could look like for one brand ourselves: every franchised Nissan dealer in the country (1,042 of them, from Nissan's August 2026 locator, supplemented with three Columbia, SC-area dealers verified November 2026) against the 2020 census, tract by tract. If future software restrictions drive more independents away, then the dealership will be the only option.

County average distance to nearest Nissan dealerResidents in those countiesShare of U.S.
0-10 miles264,243,08179.7%
11-25 miles38,272,34311.5%
26-45 miles19,363,1225.8%
46-65 miles5,121,5801.5%
66-100 miles3,431,1481.0%
Over 100 miles1,018,0070.3%
Figure 10. 1,042 U.S. Nissan dealership locations. Open full-screen map.

Without independents, the dealer network is a single point of failure. Helena, Montana, a state capital, lost its Nissan dealer. The nearest is now more than an hour's drive away, in Great Falls.

Forty-five percent of Montanans live more than 25 miles from a Nissan dealer; in Wyoming, one resident in five lives more than 100 miles from one.

Manufacturers are driving technicians away

Finding skilled technicians keeps getting harder across the industry. Technicians typically have to pay for their own hand tools. Some technicians earn a flat rate for each job, regardless of how long the job actually takes.

Frank Brown, a Michigan automotive technology instructor who spent more than 50 years in the trade, tells the story of a friend he calls Bob, a technician at a large new-car dealership. By noon one day, Bob had diagnosed three cars under warranty and ordered parts for all three. His only paid work was an oil change:

"I came to work at 7 am and its now noon. Do you know how much money I have made so far today? I have made about ten dollars for five hours of being on the job." Bob, as told by Frank Brown, September 2026

Bob gets paid for those three repairs only when the parts arrive and he installs them. If another technician does the install, Bob loses the time. He is quitting to live on Social Security and side work. Brown sees Bob as part of a bigger problem:

"The automotive repair industry is in big trouble... There is a huge technician shortage that gets worse every day. ... Something needs to change before there are no good mechanics left in the retail repair industry." Frank Brown, September 27 and September 29, 2026

Brown's concerns extend beyond one dealership. In WrenchWay and ASE's 2026 survey, 84% of technician respondents identified higher pay as the most urgent issue for addressing the technician shortage. One in five said they would probably leave the industry within five years.

Time-consuming software authentication adds to the problem. On repairs that need manufacturer software, the mechanics we surveyed spend an estimated 1.25 hours buying, downloading, logging in, and waiting. For a technician paid by the labor chart, that time can reduce their effective hourly earnings.

Illinois has already taken action. It now makes manufacturers pay dealers for warranty and other factory-paid repairs at 1.5 times the hours in their own time guide unless the two agree on different labor times. Volkswagen sued to overturn the law, saying it cost the company $10 million in 2022 alone, and the case was dismissed.

It's no wonder that it's hard for shops to attract technicians. Brown's verdict: there is "just no good reason to be an automotive technician in retail in America any longer."

Manufacturers have stacked the deck against technicians.


Chapter 5

The fine print is unfair to shops

Right to repair discussions frequently reference "fair and reasonable" pricing for software tools and repair information. But in order to pay manufacturers that supposedly fair price, shop owners have to agree to contract terms for repair tools that are neither fair nor reasonable. These overly-lawyered contracts are laughably one-sided. Just as you have no choice but to agree to a labyrinthine software license agreement to use your computer, shops have no ability to negotiate terms.

Automakers are taking advantage of the one-sided relationship to stuff these agreements with language that favors them. We read the subscription terms of six manufacturers and major data resellers so you don't have to:

GM can cut off a shop's software without notice

GM can terminate access without notice for conduct it believes violates its terms. If its service failure costs the shop money, GM disclaims liability.

GM also prohibits using its software to program a replacement module before it is installed in a vehicle, including parts prepared for sale to another shop.

Source: GM's ACDelco TDS terms, captured August 28, 2026. See Prohibited Activities, Termination of Access, and Limitation On Liability.

Stellantis gives itself permanent rights to shops' repair data

The wiTECH agreement, last revised June 29, 2020, gives Stellantis a perpetual, irrevocable license to use information it collects from the shop, including repair information. It can share that information for its business purposes, and share anonymized or aggregated information outside the company for any purpose.

The same agreement prohibits using its ECU Flash tool to program a replacement part for sale to someone else. A shop can pay for the programming tool and still be forbidden to use it to prepare a part for another shop.

Separate TechAuthority terms allow accounts to be disabled without warning for excessive traffic. A shop can request reactivation once; a second disabling ends the subscription and may mean no refund.

Sources: wiTECH agreement, sections 2(a) and 4; TechAuthority subscription terms, Excessive Downloading.

Toyota claims everyday repair information is a trade secret

Toyota's TIS terms, last updated September 10, 2022, treat the information on its repair site as confidential trade secrets. An account can be permanently disabled without notice for excessive traffic.

If a dispute cannot be settled through negotiation, Toyota requires at least two days of mediation before binding arbitration. The shop pays its own mediation costs and half the mediator's bill.

Source: Toyota TIS terms, sections 4 and 16. The agreement still allows either side to seek temporary relief from a court.

Ford sued a remote diagnostic service for using paid subscriptions

Ford does not just charge for its diagnostic software. Its license dictates where and how paying subscribers may use it, limiting access to the licensee's "internal use on Your premises for the direct repair of a vehicle." When AirPro used paid subscriptions to Ford's diagnostic software to diagnose vehicles remotely for repair shops, Ford sued them for breach of contract and copyright infringement. In 2022, a federal court sided with Ford, holding that AirPro's model breached the license because AirPro used the software for customers, on equipment at customer shops, without performing the repair itself. Ford also refuses refunds once an annual subscription has been accessed.

Source: Ford terms, Return Policy, captured August 28, 2026.

Contracts restrict shops' use of AI tools

Manufacturer contracts often restrict automated access to repair information and sharing it with outside AI services. Ford's and Toyota's diagnostic agreements restrict automated extraction by tools that could let mechanics speed up their work. GM's ACDelco TDS terms restrict copying and third-party access to repair information. Volkswagen's erWin terms require advance written consent before sharing repair information with third parties. Stellantis' agreement treats vehicle diagnostic readings as confidential company information and restricts sharing them outside the shop. Toyota prohibits unapproved automation, third-party integrations, and transmitting service information.

Even finding the terms was difficult. During our August 2026 review, we could not locate Hyundai's software license before purchase, and attempts to open GM's license agreement terms failed. GM's End User License opened without a login when we checked again in November 2026.

How are repair shops supposed to have business certainty when every tool they depend on has “we may terminate you without notice” in its contract?

Complicated contracts are preventing innovation.


Chapter 6

The Death of DIY

A generation ago, learning to fix cars started with a socket set and a Saturday. Today, it can start with a rejected login. The Hyundai owner trying to change his brake pads had the tools and the experience. What he lacked was the manufacturer's permission. Now imagine teaching a classroom full of teenagers to fix cars when the first lesson is that they need a software subscription.

Automotive programs at high schools and technical colleges have been a mainstay of American education for decades, but manufacturer software prices can put essential tools out of reach. Pete Szybatka, a diesel instructor at Dakota County Technical College in Minnesota, encountered this firsthand. "I tried to purchase some [manufacturer] software for our classroom, and it was going to be about three thousand dollars," said Szybatka. "They told me there was no educational pricing, so I hung up the phone and knew I had to figure something else out."

The high school kids locked out of fixing today's cars should be the next generation of technicians. American schools graduated just 41,726 automotive technicians in 2024, which the TechForce Foundation calculates is only 59% of what the industry needs.

None of the six manufacturers' software stores in our review offers an education, student, or hobbyist tier, forcing students to pay professional prices or go without.

Locked out of Fixing

Key and immobilizer work is completely out of reach for DIYers: it requires registering with the industry's Vehicle Security Professional program, which means $1 million in liability insurance and a $100,000 bond for shops with employees, and in 12 states plus New York City and Las Vegas, a locksmith license on top. Car owners who don't have a business license are locked out of repairing their own vehicles.

This is a new development. When the ignition lock cylinder wore out on this author's 2005 Honda Civic, the fix was a few drops of solder and a quick trip to the parts store. Aftermarket cylinders start around $30 with replacement keys, and the job took an afternoon in the driveway with a screwdriver. On a new car, the new cylinder and keys have to be paired to the immobilizer, the pairing runs through manufacturer software, and the software sits behind the registry with the million-dollar insurance requirement.

2005: your driveway

Worn ignition cylinder on a Civic. Buy the $30 part with fresh keys at the parts store, watch a how-to, swap it in an afternoon. Total: about $30 and your Saturday.

Today: a credentialed shop

The replacement has to be electronically paired to the car through gated software, so the job goes to a registered professional carrying $1 million in insurance, and the bill reflects it.

Mercedes now includes transmission control units, direct shift modules, engine control units, electric drive electronics, e-drive control units, and even alternators as “theft-relevant parts.” This overly broad anti-theft definition stretches credulity and leads technicians we interviewed to speculate that it’s a deliberate strategy to control the repair ecosystem.

Do you want to live in a world where simple car repairs are impossible for regular folks to do themselves?

Even when repairs are possible, software is frequently required. A taillight should be an approachable part to repair yourself. But on one 2018 Ford F-150, water leaking into the taillights damaged electronics that also disrupted the radio and climate controls. Diagnosing the problem required tracing faults through the truck's computer network. For someone learning in the driveway, the challenge now extends well beyond removing the broken part. Familiar repairs increasingly demand access to manufacturer software before the owner ever picks up a wrench.

What it Takes to Fix a Taillight

The information, software, and tools to diagnose a taillight electrical problem.

Repair information
$79
Ford manuals and wiring diagrams
Three 72-hour passes
Diagnostic software
+ $300
Ford diagnostic subscription
30-day access; includes IDS
Adapter and cables
+ $1,799
Ford VCM3 kit
One-time purchase
Example setup total
$2,178
Before repair parts
or mechanic labor
Our estimate of costs for one week of troubleshooting an electrical problem. Uses three 72-hour repair-information passes and one month of diagnostic software, cheaper than buying four two-day passes. Costs checked November 1, 2026. Assumes an existing Windows laptop; excludes tax, shipping, repair parts, and labor.

Charging for access to repair information has other unintended consequences. The information paywall also keeps the industry's software locks out of view. High prices and license agreements make it harder for regulators and academics to examine these restrictions. When the Government Accountability Office studied vehicle repair in 2024, it ran a formal literature search and reported that it "did not identify sufficient literature to draw broad conclusions."

Even a legal right to repair information does not guarantee practical access. Australia's Treasury concluded in February 2026 that "High costs, limited availability, and functionality restrictions of proprietary diagnostic hardware pose competitive barriers for independent workshops." If barriers are high for independent shops, they are almost insurmountable for ordinary vehicle owners.

Americans should be able to fix their cars.


Chapter 7

Service manuals should come with the car

Owners and repair shops should not have to pay for information that costs the manufacturer next to nothing to provide. A service manual is a digital file. Charging thousands of dollars to read it is a policy choice, not a business necessity. Auto manufacturers charge unusually high fees for service information. In most other industries, service documentation is included in the cost of the product.

What repair information costs across industries

To make the comparison concrete, we checked twelve product examples from a variety of industries requiring service: industrial automation and networking, material handling, data-center equipment, personal computing, additive manufacturing, and mobile devices.

ProductOfficial repair informationPrice
Tesla Model 3, 2017-2023Available$0
Rockwell T9110 industrial factory controllerAvailable$0
EKKO EK20LI electric forkliftAvailable$0
Cisco Catalyst IR1101 routerAvailable$0
HPE ProLiant DL180 serverAvailable$0
Dell Latitude 7440 laptopAvailable$0
Lenovo ThinkPad X1 Carbon laptopAvailable$0
Original Prusa 3D printerAvailable$0
Microsoft Xbox Series X game consoleAvailable$0
SRAM Guide RE mountain-bike brakes, 2017-2019Available$0
Patagonia clothing and outdoor gearAvailable$0
Apple iPhone 16 ProAvailable$0

The high fees that automakers charge for repair information are short-sighted. For many manufacturers, repairability is becoming a selling point. Edison Motors' verified YouTube channel published a video titled "Right to Repair, no planned obsolescence," while the company's website promises "parts you can fix with a wrench" and calls its diesel-electric trucks "repairable" and "built to last." That positioning is already showing up in the supply chain: Hendrickson publishes free Edison-specific service instructions for its STEERTEK NXT truck suspension, including maintenance, component replacement, troubleshooting, and rebuild procedures. Edison is using serviceability to distinguish its trucks.

Tesla's free service manual shows that cars need not be the exception. Each manufacturer on this list makes official repair information available to read free. These examples show that complexity alone does not justify a subscription toll.

Tesla proved fees aren't needed. In May 2022, Tesla cut its service-information subscription from $3,187.50 a year to zero: manuals, wiring diagrams, and parts catalogs are all free online. It later cut its diagnostic software by 76%, from $3,000 to $700 a year. Tesla still makes money selling cars. The most software-driven carmaker in the world decided that keeping its cars well maintained was more important than incremental documentation revenue.

Bar chart. Tesla cut the price of service information from $3,187.50 a year to nothing in May 2022, and diagnostic software from $3,000 to $700 a year between late 2024 and early 2025. No law required either change.$3,187.50$0Service informationbefore May 2022today$3,000$700Diagnostic softwarebefore late 2024today
Figure 11. Tesla's repair-data prices before and after its cuts: service information in May 2022, diagnostic software in late 2024 and early 2025. No law required either change.

Manufacturers already license this data wholesale. ALLDATA, Mitchell 1, and Identifix license service data directly from manufacturers under complex license agreements.

The manuals are already written. The Environmental Protection Agency requires manufacturers to provide emissions service information. The European Union requires manufacturers to provide repair information. Every franchised dealer gets it as a matter of course. The engineering is paid for in the price of the vehicle, and delivering it over the internet costs next to nothing. Charging independent shops thousands a year for it charges the public twice for the same documents.

Europe and Australia have price caps. European law requires fees that are "reasonable and proportionate" and that "shall not discourage access." Australia caps the price at fair market value and names reasonable cost recovery as a factor in setting it. The American standard, "fair and reasonable," is undefined and unenforced, and much higher American prices are the result.

And Australia is cracking down. In August 2026, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission took Subaru Australia to the Federal Court. The ACCC alleges that Subaru failed to give independent repairers the same information it gave dealers, sometimes offered only remote assistance, required special hardware, and sold access only by the year instead of by the day, month, or repairer-selected period.

But any fee adds unnecessary friction to an already challenged industry. Service information and diagnostic software should be free.

Arguments Against Free Public Information

Manufacturers defend the fees two ways: the information is sensitive intellectual property, and open access is a safety risk. The record supports neither.

On intellectual property: the same manufacturers already license the same data to wholesalers. If the information was sensitive, they wouldn’t provide access to tens of thousands of mechanics. Charging for it doesn’t help protect those secrets: competitors seeking information about new products have no problem paying these fees. Tesla, one of the most innovative automakers, publishes its manuals freely without giving up its competitive position.

On safety: having the correct repair information helps people service a vehicle safely. Someone who cannot afford the manual, or chooses not to pay for it, may still replace their brakes without knowing how tightly to fasten the bolts that hold the brake caliper in place. Those details matter: improperly secured caliper bolts can loosen and increase the risk of a crash. Putting instructions behind a paywall can leave people attempting the same repair with less information, making the work less safe.

The Federal Trade Commission reviewed manufacturers' justifications for repair restrictions across industries in 2021 and concluded: "Although manufacturers have offered numerous explanations for their repair restrictions, the majority are not supported by the record."

Service manuals should be freely available for everyone.


Chapter 8

Proprietary Driver Assistance Technologies Have Unexpected Costs

Advanced driver-assistance systems (lane-keeping, automatic emergency braking, adaptive cruise control) have gone from options to standard equipment. By 2023, five of them were on more than 90% of new cars, and the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration will require automatic emergency braking on every new passenger vehicle by 2029.

ABPA: modern vehicles integrate overlapping sensor systems
Figure 12. Modern vehicles run overlapping camera, radar, ultrasonic, and LiDAR systems, so one repair often means calibrating several of them. Graphic courtesy of the Automotive Body Parts Association, "TOTALED: The Real Costs of Vehicle Loss" (2026).

These systems run on sensors, and the sensors need calibrating both at the factory and after a windshield swap, a bumper repair, an alignment, and sometimes after ordinary driving. Each manufacturer devises its own arbitrary system of calibration targets and pairing software. Those tools differ by manufacturer with no industry standard. The equipment costs tens of thousands of dollars and needs a large, level, uncluttered indoor space that many shops do not have.

Of the shops we surveyed, 62% have no calibration equipment at all, and two-thirds (66%) turned away a repair in the past year because of calibration requirements.

The result is a safety problem. Rolling out proprietary sensors without an industry-wide plan for equipping repair shops with standardized equipment has created chaos. The average calibration charge on collision claims nearly doubled in five years, to about $500, and CCC claims data suggests roughly 75% of the calibrations cars need are not done. Cars are on the road with safety systems out of specification because calibrating them is priced and fragmented out of reach.

There are two potential fixes. One: publish the calibration specifications and target geometries and let any toolmaker build to them. Two: create industry-standard tools and calibrations so that the same tools can be used for all vehicles. A lane camera does not care whose logo is on the target board.

There is a glimmer of hope on the horizon. Tesla, comma.ai, Waymo, and others are developing driver-assistance and automated-driving systems around AI models and cameras or lidar. More capable software could make the jumble of sensors in today's cars obsolete.

Automakers should pursue more adaptable sensing and software, with systems that detect misalignment and recalibrate themselves. Some already do: Tesla documents camera self-calibration while driving. Comma.ai detects changes in camera mounting and automatically restarts calibration. Rivian's cameras now calibrate themselves while driving, a process that previously required a service appointment. In the future, more calibration work will be handled by the vehicle itself. Manufacturers should reduce dependence on specialized targets and equipment, and make the remaining procedures open and standardized.

More flexible machine learning may free us from overly specific sensor calibrations.

Driver assistance tools should be standardized or replaced with more flexible AI systems.


Chapter 9

Parts: a radio that only works in one car

Parts locked to one car

A relatively new practice is to use software to lock parts to the specific car they were originally installed in. The trade calls it "VIN burning," where the Vehicle Identification Number is 'burned' into the part. In phones and laptops the same practice is called parts pairing, and three states have banned it.

Pairing a part to a particular vehicle is straightforward. A computerized part, a radio or a control module, is assigned an identity tied to the car's VIN. Move that part to an identical car and the software checks the number, finds a mismatch, and refuses to work. The part is fine, but it will not work.

America scraps about 10 million vehicles a year, a steady supply of working parts that the repair industry relies on. VIN burning removes these parts from the market. Getting a salvaged module to run requires the manufacturer's software or a dealer's pairing fee, and the fee can eat up the savings. Volkswagen charges $300 to $500 to unlock a salvaged electronic module. As Gadget Review put it: "That creates an impossible math problem: why pay $400 to activate a $200 part when you could buy new for $600?"

PartSalvagedNew from manufacturerSavings after pairing feeSavings, no pairing
2017 Chevrolet Equinox radio$110$53442%79%
2018 Honda CR-V engine control module$135$65048%79%
2019 Hyundai Elantra body control module$109$250-24%56%
2021 Ford F-150 air bag control module$183$54730%67%
2022 Mercedes-Benz GLC300 rear body control module$74$163-68%55%
Figure 13. Salvaged parts cost a fraction of new manufacturer parts, until pairing fees eat the savings. “After pairing” assumes a $200 fee to pair the salvaged module. Median price of reviewed salvaged parts.

Manufacturers defend VIN-burning as theft prevention, but its use in parts buried deep in the vehicle belies that argument. Regardless, an owner who hands an old stereo to a friend is not a thief. The parts belong to the person who owns the car. At minimum, owners should be able to turn pairing off free of charge for parts from their own vehicle.

VIN locking parts should be illegal.


Chapter 10

What lawmakers should do

  1. Give owners control over their wireless vehicle data. Mandate that manufacturers equip their vehicles with a standardized platform for accessing telematics repair data. This will allow independent mechanics to compete with car dealerships. Wireless repair data should go directly to owners, who should be the ones deciding who has access to their repair information. They bought the car; they should have direct access to the information needed to fix it.
  2. Stop requiring secure gateways for routine repairs. No manufacturer should require a business license to fix a seat, a screen, or a trunk latch. Access to functions that are genuinely security-related should run through standardized, manufacturer-neutral vetting similar to NASTF and SERMI, not through per-brand fees. Eliminate business obstacles to accessing and programming parts.
  3. Allow vehicle owners to repair anything on their car. Today, authentication and access are at the manufacturer's discretion and can be repriced or revoked at will. Some even require a business license. Require every manufacturer to support a standard protocol for authenticating independent tools. Proprietary authentication only allows the manufacturers to charge whatever they want, to whomever they want, whenever they want. Limiting access is unfair to car owners and independent repair shops who need up-to-date and fast information.
  4. Make service information and basic diagnostic software free. Publicly accessible documentation will enable innovation and encourage more local repair activity. Tesla already does it. The engineering is paid for with the car. Thirteen years of experience living under the automotive MOU have shown that "fair and reasonable" means nothing.
  5. Cap software prices. High per-manufacturer prices inordinately penalize independent shops and DIY mechanics. Limit the total price of everything required to repair a car to $100/month or $1,000/year.

Restore the Right to Repair our vehicles.


Methodology

How we got these numbers

The survey

We surveyed independent repair professionals on their software spending, the share of their repairs that require manufacturer software, and the time they lose to software-related labor. Sample sizes vary by question: 47 shops for ADAS, 28 for time estimates, and 50 valid responses for technical support. Every survey finding carries the qualifier "of the mechanics we surveyed": this is a self-selected sample, not a probability sample, and shops in California and Massachusetts, both Right to Repair states, are overrepresented in it.

The time model

The model uses bucket midpoints and medians. We exclude seven inconsistent time responses and assign 30 minutes to repairs under one hour. The national figure combines the survey with Department of Energy vehicle-registration counts and Cox Automotive service-visit frequency. At an assumed shop rate of $140 an hour, that time is worth about $12 billion a year. The 2030 figure is a scenario, not a forecast. The 42,000 comparison uses a 2,000-hour technician-year.

Prices, contracts, and the map

Manufacturer prices were checked on manufacturer and authorized-reseller sites in August 2026. Contract quotations come from the vendors' own published terms, retrieved August 2026.

We used 2020 Census tract populations and population centers. Our list of 1,042 Nissan dealerships combines 1,039 locations from the August 28, 2026 dealer locator snapshot with three locations verified on November 1, 2026. For each tract, we measured straight-line distance from its population center to the nearest listed dealer, including dealers outside the county. The map averages those distances within each county, weighting each tract by its population.


Acknowledgements

Contributors

This report grew out of the research and persistence of many people. We thank Jack Frimet and Julius Shieh, former campaign associates with U.S. PIRG Education Fund, for research and gathering accounts from repair professionals; Kevin O'Reilly, executive director of Fulu, for research on parts and software restrictions; and Nathan Proctor, senior Right to Repair campaign director for U.S. PIRG Education Fund, for shaping the research, analysis, and argument. We are especially grateful to Elizabeth Ridlington, associate director of the Frontier Group, for her detailed fact-checking, data review, and editorial guidance.

Expert advice and assistance

We are incredibly grateful to Lisa Foshee, Mike Tanner, Donovan Ringo, Stacey Miller, and Jonathan Larsen of the Auto Care Association for sharing their knowledge of the repair industry, helping us understand repair roadblocks, and assisting our research. We’d also like to thank the Automotive Body Parts Association, including Edward Salamy and Sean Kennedy, for sharing research and perspectives on collision repair and replacement parts.

Tommy Hickey helped sharpen the policy recommendations. Willie Cade, Repair.org board member and repair industry expert, shared research and feedback on agricultural policy. Tony Dutzik, associate director of the Frontier Group, provided advice on the dealer-map analysis. Their expertise helped us ask better questions and strengthen the report.

Finally, we thank the repair professionals who took our survey and shared their experiences. Their time and practical knowledge made this report possible.

The authors are responsible for the report's conclusions and any errors. Acknowledgement does not imply endorsement.